| Player | School | Graduating Year |
| Ellis Llewellyn | Franklin and Marshall | 2015 |
| Drew Monroe | DePauw | 2015 |
| Ian Levin | Hampden-Sydney | 2014 |
| William McEntee | Air Force Academy | 2013 |
| Ryan Dotson | Dean College | 2013 |
| Tate Beason | Florida Tech/Catawba College | 2012 |
| Chandler Zirkle | Guilford College | 2011 |
| Ryan Lucey | Salisbury University | 2011 |
| Kord Scharfenberg | Virginia Military Institute | 2010 |
| Noel Myers | Oberlin College | 2010 |
| Dan Eron | Catawba College | 2009 |
| Karsten Bench | Virginia Military Institute | 2009 |
| Scot Meyer | Duke University | 2008 |
| Will Devlin | Mary Washington University | 2008 |
| Sepp Stephens | McGill University | 2007 |
| Tony Mendes | Salisbury University/University of Maryland | 2007 |
| Gates Benson | Guilford College | 2005 |
